Obama’s Stem Cell Policy

President Bush’s 2001 executive order regarding federal funding for embryonic stem cell research was one of the wisest, most thought-through, reasonable decisions of his time in office.

Contrary to his ill-deserved reputation as an anti-intellectual and impulsive decision maker, he spent months considering what his administration’s position on the research would be. He listened to arguments from all sides. Basically the dilemma was this: there is potential for medical treatments to be developed from embryonic stem cells, but creating more “lines” of these stem cells for research typically involves the destruction of human embryos– the destruction of human life.

In the end, he came up with a reasonable and ethical middle road. He permitted federal funding for research on the twenty-odd existing stem cell lines, but not for the creation of new ones. This permitted research to go forward without our government– that is, taxpayer money– funding the destruction of human genetic material.

(Update: Charles Krauthammer, a brilliant commentator with something of a personal stake in this research, said this last night:

I disagreed with where Bush ended up drawing the line on permissible research, but he gave in August of 2001 the single most morally serious presidential speech on medical ethics ever given, and Obama did not, even though… I agree more on where he ended up.)

Reading the headlines recently, you’d never know any of this. Most articles have said something like “The Bush administration cut off federal funding for stem cell research,” which is nothing short of a lie. But when President Obama reversed this decision yesterday, he contributed to this false view of Bush’s policy, saying “Our government has forced what I believe is a false choice between sound science and moral values.” Bush forced no such false choice– he allowed the science to go forward in a manner consistent with moral values.

Obama, on the other hand, has removed all ethical constraints of any kind from embryonic stem cell research (which many believe is far less promising than ethically-unproblematic adult stem cell research). As the editors of National Review put it, “Obama has not so much staked out a position in the embryo debate as dismissed the debate itself as unnecessary.”

It remains to be seen whether embryonic stem cell research can live up to its hype. (You may recall the 2004 campaign, when John Edwards declared “If we can do the work that we can do in this country — the work we will do when John Kerry is president — people like Christopher Reeve are going to walk. Get up out of that wheelchair and walk again.”) But even if the wildest-dream, best-case scenario happens– say, a cure for Alzheimer’s or Parkinson’s– and it’s brought about by the destruction of human life, we won’t have gained anything.

Advertisements

Comments

  1. So this is Bush Bashing 2009’s latest hit. As the schtick of blasting the previous administration’s policies is wildly popular with the Crowd, I can understand why they do it, but the Obama Administration’s incessant need to take pot-shots at the previous administration is growing increasingly petty and shrill.

    And in this instance, they both substitute any reasoned rationale (moral or otherwise) on this issue (at least publicly) with the petty pot-shots and manage to outright lie about what the Bush Administration did. They’re going backwards.

    The NR editors make an important point, but Obama has staked out his position. To enact this kind of law is to make a definitive statement on the debate over embryo’s. He’s declared for all to see that if – if! – there’s a chance destroying untold numbers of embryo’s will help us down the line cure a disease or disorder then go forth and prosper with his full sanction and our funding. By all means kill the weakest on the theory that by doing so you’ll help the weak.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s